Looks at estimates for a projects costs, benefits and duration in the absence of robust primary evidence, providing cost and time uplift percentages for. Aside from that it is important to acknowledge the points that optimism bias can be beneficial, despite being called a bias. Thus the base case npv for each option is its obadjusted npv. Optimism bias is the tendency for us to believe that we are less likely to experience negative events than others and to act on that optimistic belief the classic it wont happen to me. The term optimism bias is used, both in the green book and in this paper, as a measure of.
Methodology reduce optimism bias as contributory risk factors are identified and costs of risk management are included in the full business case prior to contract. The hmt green book includes guidance on how to discount benefits and costs to obtain the value for money of an investment and how to account for risk and uncertainty in appraisal. The green book is hm treasury guidance for central government, setting out a framework for the appraisal and evaluation of all policies, programmes and projects. It aims to make the appraisal process throughout government more consistent and transparent. But it is one that persists, frequently undermining projects value for money as time and cost are under estimated and benefits over estimated. Discounting 101 list of green book supplementary guidance 107. Green book which contains specific advice on appraisal and evaluation in central government, the office of government commerces management of risk which provides more detailed guidance on the practical application of the principles and concepts contained in. Risk and optimism bias green book supplementary guidance on risk. Mata has developed three options which meet their business needs to varying degrees. Optimism bias is the proven tendency for appraisers to be too optimistic about key project parameters. Measure the success of the change initiative martin.
The british department for transport, procedures for dealing with optimism bias in transport planning guidance document, june 2004 bent flyvbjerg in association with. In practice, the main issue to be addressed is optimism bias. Supplementary green book guidance optimism bias hm treasury 4 15 means that contributory factors are not mitigated at all, 1. Theyre actually more realistic than healthy individuals. Sustainable services programme final draft strategic outline case for submission to sath trust board 22 march 2016. Overcoming optimism bias in project decision making. Contingency allocation for the whitmore heath to madeley. But individuals with severe depression, they have a pessimistic bias. Tali sharot shares new research that suggests our brains are wired to look on the bri. The bias was first demonstrated by weinstein 1980, who reported that a majority of college. Schoolchildren playing whenigrowup are rampant optimists, but so are grownups. If expectations are better than reality, the bias is optimistic. Green book which contains specific advice on appraisal and evaluation in central government, the office of government commerces management of risk which provides more detailed guidance on the practical application of the principles and concepts contained in this publication, and guidance provided by. Optimism bias and mitigation have been assessed in accordance with the optimism bias guidance on dh nhs build specific andor hmt.
The two main causes of optimism bias in estimates of capital costs are. The government andor transport scotland comments but ultimate responsibility for setting the level of optimism bias. Business planning and business cases the development and. The methodology adopted is consistent with hm treasury green book and sg guidance and covers a 20 year operational period. Its rollout should be accompanied by an extensive training programme with appropriate support provided for senior civil servants and ministers, as well as analysts. Optimism bias and political bias are both deception, but where the latter is deliberate, the former is not. Optimism bias and mitigation have been assessed in accordance with the optimism bias guidance on dh nhs build specific andor hmt websites. Optimistic biases are even reported in nonhuman animals such as rats and birds. Tali sharot shares new research that suggests our brains are wired to look on the bright side and how that can be both dangerous and beneficial. An optimism bias of 44% was applied to reflect a demonstrated systematic, tendency for project appraisers to be overly optimistic hmt green book, 2003, p.
Improving cost benefit analysis the institute for government. Measure the success of the change initiative martin gosden 1st group 1. Table 1 recorded average optimism bias for traditional procurement optimism bias % works duration capex opex benefits shortfall 17 47 41 2 1 the green book. This page lists a number of guides to specific types of impact assessment including health, environment and transport among others. However, its principles are broadly in accord with those.
It keeps us moving forward, rather than to the nearest highrise ledge. The supplementary and departmental guidance contains more detailed guidance on specific issues and applying the green book. The green book is the treasurys guidance on appraising project or policy. Useful links for developing appraisals department of finance. People with mild depression, they dont have a bias when they look into the future. Dec 31, 2012 but the optimism bias also protects and inspires us.
The green book supplementary guidance on optimism bias, hm treasury 5. Louisa jewell, positive psychology news daily an intelligently written look into why most people take an optimistic view of life. Optimism bias in public sector projects is not a new phenomenon. The treasury should streamline the green book guidance and make it more user friendly. Postproject optimism is an overly optimistic belief. In addition to the main guidance document, the green book includes additional documents as supplementary guidance. Only go outside for food, health reasons or work but only if you cannot work from home if you go out, stay 2 metres 6ft away from other people at all times. Optimism bias supplementary green book guidance, hm treasury. The base case for each option is the best estimate of its costs and benefits after allowance for appraisal optimism. Are we born to be optimistic, rather than realistic.
Supplementary guidance to the green book on estimates for a projects costs, benefits and duration in the absence of robust primary evidence. The rt is aware there are a number of important specification issues still to be decided by lbh such as the status of breeam which will have an impact on the final scheme cost. The optimism bias is defined as the difference between a persons expectation and the outcome that follows. Alternatively, estimates can be built up in the traditional manner and then adjusted by set percentages based on past performance this is the approach used in the uk central government where a standard set of optimism bias adjustments are included in the hmt green book. Apr 18, 20 the green book is guidance issued by hm treasury on how to appraise policies, programmes and projects. What is economic appraisal and when is it required. The green book therefore constitutes binding guidance for departments and executive. People often oppose anything labelled a bias or fallacy, and while that is fair in pure economics or logic, it might not apply in general life. Adjustments should be empirically based eg using data from past projects or similar projects elsewhere. Generally, during the early phases of capital projects, hmt green book guidance requires the adjustment of the cost estimate to allow for optimism bias. Finally,there is greater emphasis on assessing the. Klein, university of pittsburgh definition and history optimistic bias is commonly defined as the mistaken belief that ones chances of experiencing a negative event are lower or a positive event higher than that of ones peers. The guidance consolidates other reference sources and is consistent with hm treasury s green book guidance on appraisal of policies, programmes and projects, which it should be read in conjunction with it. Copies of this guidance and of the green book and of related supplementary.
Apr 21, 20 supplementary guidance to the green book on estimates for a projects costs, benefits and duration in the absence of robust primary evidence. It is also known as unrealistic optimism or comparative optimism optimism bias is common and transcends gender, ethnicity, nationality and age. Procedures for dealing with optimism bias in transport planning, flyvbjerg, b. May 28, 2011 the belief that the future will be much better than the past and present is known as the optimism bias. This series brings together all documents relating to hmt green book.
Optimism bias or the optimistic bias is a cognitive bias that causes someone to believe that they themselves are less likely to experience a negative event. A thoughtprovoking research paper in the augustseptember 2014 issue of project management journa. Further supplementary memorandum submitted by the hm treasury discount rate. Step eight calculate net present values and assess. Uk nda application of reference class forecasting in. Apr 26, 20 are we born to be optimistic, rather than realistic. The purpose of this guidance is to ensure that policies, programs and projects adopted are the best ways to achieve policy objectives and make the best use of public resources. A new form of optimism bias, namely postproject optimism bias, is defined.
Early financial cost estimates of infrastructure programmes and projects and the treatment of uncertainty and risk. This is based on hm treasury s advice on evidencebased decision making as set out in the green book 2 and uses the best practice five case model approach. Further hm treasury guidance, including adjustment percentages for generic project. Optimism bias is common and transcends gender, ethnicity, nationality and age. A tour of the irrationally positive brain by tali sharot the optimism bias is the interesting book that investigates optimism bias. There is a demonstrated, systematic, tendency for project appraisers to be overly. Supplementary guidance to the green book on estimates for a. Supplementary green book guidance optimism bias hm treasury 415 means that contributory factors are not mitigated at all, 1. Optimism bias adjustment optimism bias ob defined in hm treasury green book supplementary guidance as. May 14, 2012 are we born to be optimistic, rather than realistic. It abides in every race, region and socioeconomic bracket. Procurement issues including conventional and pfippp. Uk nda application of reference class forecasting in optimism.
Upper bound optimism bias % 1 hm treasury green book five case model guidance hm treasury supplementary guidance on optimism bias. It explores when the bias is adaptive and when it is destructive, and it provides evidence that moderately optimistic. Procurement in the uk, mott macdonald 2002, available at. Guide to developing the project business case 1 1 introduction a project management approach is essential for the delivery of a set of related products and activities, in order to ensure effective management, benefits realisation and value for.
This report uses our back catalogue to illustrate the consequences of over optimism. This guidance discusses the underlying causes and institutional context for optimism bias in british transport projects and discusses some possibilities for reducing it. Once i started reading the optimism bias, i could not put it down. Following consultation last year, a new edition of the green book was published on 16 january 2003. The hmt green book includes guidance on how to discount benefits and costs to obtain. These include specific chapters on topics such as optimism bias. The green book sets out the broad framework for the appraisal and evaluation of all policies, programmes and projects. The pfs guidance for a nonlep bsf project does not require a hmt green book optimism bias and sensitivity analysis to be undertaken, but relies on the outputs from the fam and the affordability assessment undertaken by the council and its. The green book is guidance issued by hm treasury on how to appraise policies, programmes and projects.
The business case points out that this reduction is not due to mitigating individual risks, but due to progress to varying degrees in the management of all of the 237 identified project risks. It is also known as unrealistic optimism or comparative optimism. This research presents the findings from an experiment that invesigated to what extent decision makers suffer from optimism bias when escalating a commitment to failing projects. The orange book sets out a framework for the development and implementation of risk management processes in government organisations. Risks must firstly be identified, then assessed through an evaluation of the likelihood of each risk occurring and an evaluation of the impact if the risk does occur, then addressed. The current hm treasury green book discount rate is 3. Hm treasury, green book appraisal and evaluation in central. Procedures for dealing with optimism bias in transport. It also provides guidance on the design and use of monitoring and evaluation before, during and after implementation. Political bias can be traced to political and organizational pressures, for instance competition for scarce funds or jockeying for position, and to lack of incentive alignment. Pdf procedures for dealing with optimism bias in transport.
Appraisal and evaluation in central government hm treasury. Effect of optimism bias decision to terminate failing projects. Review of large public procurement in the uk, mott macdonald july 2002 7. The orange book, management of risk principles and concepts, hm treasury 20 6. The business case points out that this reduction is not due to mitigating individual risks, but due to progress to varying degrees. A fascinating trip into why we prefer to remain hopeful about our future and ourselves. Green book team hm treasury horse guards road london sw1a 2hq generic appraisal summary table appraisal summary table. Step six assess risks and adjust for optimism bias. Portfolio investment lead office for national statistics. Overoptimism in government projects national audit office. Is optimism bias properly included and aligned with risk. It explores when the bias is adaptive and when it is destructive, and it provides evidence that moderately optimistic illusions can promote wellbeing. Alternatively, estimates can be built up in the traditional manner and then adjusted by set percentages based on past performance this is the approach used in the uk central government where a standard set of optimism bias described in the section below adjustments are included in the hmt green book.
In fact, without the optimism bias, we would all be slightly depressed. The full text of the 2003 hm treasury green book appraisal and evaluation in. The guidance consolidates other reference sources and is consistent with hm treasury s green book guidance on appraisal of policies, programmes and. Includes hm treasury s orange book guide to risk management and other relevant resources. Hm treasury supplementary guidance on the treatment of optimism bias.
1328 1298 566 130 1352 864 1181 1443 1401 283 130 306 504 148 1370 1597 378 167 440 1162 1122 207 1228 705 1509 167 291 922 1302 603 777 806